Hiring the right candidate starts long before the interview. It begins with a comprehensive review of their résumé. Unfortunately, not all résumés are truthful. Research reveals that a significant portion of job seekers provide inaccurate information. According to Forbes, 70% of workers admit to stretching the truth on their résumés. Top Universities equally report that 33% of graduates have also been found to falsify key details. While a strong résumé should highlight relevant skills and solid experience, many applications contain red flags that could signal issues down the line. Recognizing these warning signs early in the hiring process can save you from making costly mistakes. Here’s what to look out for when screening résumés to ensure you’re selecting the right fit.
While job changes are common, a pattern of frequent job hopping is a bad signal. If a candidate has moved between multiple positions and companies in a short time, it may indicate a lack of commitment, performance issues, or difficulty adapting to workplaces. You can however look for explanations in the cover letter or interview.
Career breaks are normal, but large, unexplained gaps raise concerns. If a candidate cannot clarify why they were unemployed for long periods, it is a wrong signal. They should be able to give valid reasons like furthering their education, or taking a course to prepare them for a full scale job transition. The candidate should also show efforts in trying to address these gaps.
Résumés filled with words like “results-driven,” or “strategic thinker” without supporting evidence can be misleading. Strong candidates back up claims with achievements. Instead of simply stating they are “highly skilled in sales,” a genuine candidate will provide specifics like “I increased quarterly sales by 35% through a new client acquisition strategy.”
4. Spelling and Grammar Errors
Errors in a résumé indicate poor attention to detail which can be a concern in roles requiring precision and communication. If a candidate fails to proofread their résumé, they might also be careless in their work. Additionally, poor formatting such as inconsistent font styles or improper spacing makes a résumé hard to read and may reflect disorganization.
Candidates sometimes exaggerate their job titles or responsibilities to appear more qualified. If someone claims to have been a "Senior Manager" within a year of graduating or shows rapid, unexplained career leaps, verify the details. Cross-check social media profiles, references, or company websites to ensure credibility.
A candidate may list advanced skills (such as coding, project management, or leadership) without relevant experience in their work history. If someone claims to be proficient in software development but has only worked in sales, it raises questions. Ensure that skills are supported by actual work experience or relevant certifications.
View 9 Reasons Why Your CV Is Being Dumped
If a candidate has spent years in the same role without promotions or increased responsibilities, it may indicate they are struggling with their performance. It could even be a case of lack of ambition. While some industries have slower career progression, top performers typically demonstrate growth, either by getting new responsibilities, leading projects, or upskilling. Ask about their long-term contributions in an interview.
An email like “pwettyshade@gmail.com” or “charlesfrosh92@yahoo.com” does not leave a good impression. A professional candidate should use a formal email with their name and not nicknames. If they haven’t taken this basic step, they may not take the job seriously.
View The Information You Should Remove from Your CV
A résumé that looks like it was mass-submitted to multiple employers without customization suggests a lack of genuine interest. If a candidate doesn’t tailor their résumé to highlight how their skills match the job, they may not be fully invested in the opportunity.
A professional résumé should include up-to-date contact details. If phone numbers or emails are missing, it could mean the applicant doesn’t want to be reached. In some cases, it might indicate an attempt to hide something.
While contract roles are common, an excessive number of short-term positions without full-time experience can be concerning. It may indicate difficulty in securing permanent roles or adapting to long-term commitments.
A cluttered, difficult-to-read résumé suggests a lack of organizational skills. A well-structured résumé should be clear, concise, and easy to skim. Poor formatting may reflect the candidate’s approach to work.
View CV Checklist - 11 Steps to Build A Great CV in 2025
A résumé that only lists job duties without specific accomplishments suggests mediocrity. Strong candidates highlight their impact, such as “Developed a marketing campaign that increased customer engagement by 40%”. This is better than “Responsible for managing social media”.
Some candidates copy and paste job descriptions instead of describing their actual contributions. If a résumé looks too polished but lacks personalization, ask for specifics in an interview. A good candidate will provide unique insights into his or her responsibilities.
Inconsistent start and end dates across different jobs can indicate dishonesty or poor attention to detail. Always verify employment history or carry out reference checks.
A candidate who lists a degree but doesn’t mention the university or graduation year might be hiding something. Always verify credentials, especially for roles requiring specific qualifications.
A candidate who claims to have jumped from an intern to a senior executive within a short period may be exaggerating. While some fast promotions happen, they should be supported by clear accomplishments and references.
Freelance work is common, but if a candidate frequently lists self-employment between short-term jobs, verify the legitimacy. It could indicate difficulty in maintaining stable employment.
Most jobs require teamwork. If a résumé only highlights solo achievements, it may suggest poor collaboration skills. Look for signs of cross-functional work, leadership, or team-based accomplishments.
An impressive résumé is expected, but an unrealistically flawless one should raise red flags. If a candidate lists rapid promotions, an extensive skill set, and continuous employment without any gaps, verify its accuracy. While high achievers exist, exaggerated or fabricated résumés are common. A genuine candidate will have a reasonable career trajectory that is supported by achievements.
A single red flag doesn’t always mean a candidate is unsuitable, but multiple warning signs should prompt further investigation. The best hiring decisions come from thorough résumé reviews, structured interviews, and diligent background checks. Taking the time to identify red flags early can save your company from costly hiring mistakes and ensure you bring the right talent on board.
Leave a Comment